A steering damper is designed to
a) Stop harmonic steering oscillation (increasing wobbles / shakes) caused by solid front axle geometry
b) reduce steering harshness due to unformed roads.
It does this by damping.
It is not designed to help the car stter straight.
An RTC damper has a spring on it, this spring will tend to want to have it's own oscillation, needing it's own damping.
Would this spring partialyl defeat the damper, making oscillation and shaking problems worse?
Paul
Notice: We request that you don't just set up a new account at this time if you are a previous user.
If you used to be one of our moderators, please feel free to reach out to Chris via the facebook Outerlimits4x4 group and he will get you set back up with access should he need you.
If you used to be one of our moderators, please feel free to reach out to Chris via the facebook Outerlimits4x4 group and he will get you set back up with access should he need you.
Recovery:If you cannot access your old email address and don't remember your password, please click here to log a change of email address so you can do a password reset.
Is an RTC damper a self defeating exercise?
Moderators: toaddog, TWISTY, V8Patrol, Moderators
Is an RTC damper a self defeating exercise?
Lexus LX470 - hrrm Winter Tyres
Gone - Cruiser HZJ105 Turbo'd Locked & Lifted
Gone - 3L Surf
Gone - Cruiser HZJ105 Turbo'd Locked & Lifted
Gone - 3L Surf
You will be better off with a Dobinsons steering damper.
The cheaper RTC has a useless damper on it so within a relatively short time it will expire leaving you with a spring that makes it harder on the steering box and you for the tight corners.
A small percentage of people would be better off with an RTC.
For straight driving the spring doesn't do anything but you don't drive straight,
so for anything that isn't straight the spring will put some side forces on the steering reducing bad Patrol setup (worn bushes etc) oscillation.
I suppose when going dead straight and if the steering damper was stuffed then the spring may increase oscillation but it would have to be in phase with the bad Patrol setup oscillations. Someone else will have to report on their experiences in this regard.
So harder to steer, harder on steering box and not good when damper dies.
60-90% of people will be happy with an RTC damper.
99.9% of people will be happy with a Dobinsons steering damper.
From someone who sells stuff, I like the odds better with the Dobinsons steering damper.
By the way, those percentages are just an estimation.
Shane
The cheaper RTC has a useless damper on it so within a relatively short time it will expire leaving you with a spring that makes it harder on the steering box and you for the tight corners.
A small percentage of people would be better off with an RTC.
For straight driving the spring doesn't do anything but you don't drive straight,
so for anything that isn't straight the spring will put some side forces on the steering reducing bad Patrol setup (worn bushes etc) oscillation.I suppose when going dead straight and if the steering damper was stuffed then the spring may increase oscillation but it would have to be in phase with the bad Patrol setup oscillations. Someone else will have to report on their experiences in this regard.
So harder to steer, harder on steering box and not good when damper dies.
60-90% of people will be happy with an RTC damper.
99.9% of people will be happy with a Dobinsons steering damper.
From someone who sells stuff, I like the odds better with the Dobinsons steering damper.
By the way, those percentages are just an estimation.
Shane
Last edited by Suspension Stuff on Mon Aug 04, 2008 10:52 am, edited 1 time in total.
We sell SUSPENSION - PRICES on
https://www.suspensionstuff.com.au" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Free Freight 1300 048 991
FLEXY COILS - Superior Engineering - TIGERZ11 - Tough Dog - PROCOMP - Polyair - ETC
https://www.suspensionstuff.com.au" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Free Freight 1300 048 991
FLEXY COILS - Superior Engineering - TIGERZ11 - Tough Dog - PROCOMP - Polyair - ETC
As I understand it, the RTC dampers are a bandaid for insufficient castor.
However, I don't see that the RTC damper would be self defeating. In concept, there is not an inherent problem with effectively using the same mounting points on the steering for (a) a damper and (b) a component that adds some modest extra centering. If it was well designed it would have a graduated "fall to the centre" kind of effect that was just a match for what castor gives, and only act when you are close to the centre already. But I am not saying that RTC dampers you can buy actually do this that way.
Just my thoughts without having really thought it over for a long time... one thing is for sure they are no substitute for properly fixing the steering imho.
However, I don't see that the RTC damper would be self defeating. In concept, there is not an inherent problem with effectively using the same mounting points on the steering for (a) a damper and (b) a component that adds some modest extra centering. If it was well designed it would have a graduated "fall to the centre" kind of effect that was just a match for what castor gives, and only act when you are close to the centre already. But I am not saying that RTC dampers you can buy actually do this that way.
Just my thoughts without having really thought it over for a long time... one thing is for sure they are no substitute for properly fixing the steering imho.
This is not legal advice.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests