winch question

[coopster]

which of these winches would you choose

t max 9000
or
ironman 9000

or just buy a second hand warn

[GQ WAGHOON]

l am also interested in both of these winches, but l would say that most people would recommend that you buy a second hand Warn.

[joeblow]

think the t-max and ironman come from the same chinese factory.

[Mousie]

hey dont laff,

if your not arfter a winch for speed,
neather of them are fast eather,

i run an ALDI winch there from the same factory too

500$ for a 9500 pund winch, i`v done probly 20+ decent recoverys

and i winch my self out of a vally wen i lost front drive used it for about 2 and half hours, only break i gave it was to re-jig the cables n shit every 20 meters, i also run 2 cranking batteries tho.

[[gubeaut]]

i've got the t-max 11000lb and the winch itself is good but i don't recomend the cordless remote.i have had heaps of dramas with mine and because they don't have solinoids when it stops you have to replace the whole control box plus the remote and antenae $500ish.

[tigerz11]

i've got the t-max 11000lb and the winch itself is good but i don't recomend the cordless remote.i have had heaps of dramas with mine and because they don't have solinoids when it stops you have to replace the whole control box plus the remote and antenae $500ish.

you can easily find replacement parts for t-max,, solenoid $99 ,,wireless remote $39 ,,or whole control box $140 which has hand & wireless remote including the single solenoid,, there are many solutions out there now.. for winches,

[Ruffy]

They do all come from the same factory but they are not all built to the same specification.
For my money, I'd go the T Max
For under a grand you get a quality cheap winch with after sales support.

[tigerz11]

They do all come from the same factory but they are not all built to the same specification.
For my money, I'd go the T Max
For under a grand you get a quality cheap winch with after sales support.

WHAT A LOAD OF BULLSHIT

[chpd80]

They do all come from the same factory but they are not all built to the same specification.
For my money, I'd go the T Max
For under a grand you get a quality cheap winch with after sales support.

Ruffy IS right, they do come out of the same factory but built to the specs asked. I have a 9500 Ironman which the specs have been upgraded to a sealed solenoid box and straight cut gears from previous years. Unless you actually work in the factory they are made in in china you can only go on what is told to us.

tigerz11 - your embarassing yourself coming out with that kind of statement, everyone is entitled to an opinion but you would look better writing down why you thought it was bull*&%$, but that would take some literacy now wouldnt it.

[tigerz11]

They do all come from the same factory but they are not all built to the same specification.
For my money, I'd go the T Max
For under a grand you get a quality cheap winch with after sales support.

Ruffy IS right, they do come out of the same factory but built to the specs asked. I have a 9500 Ironman which the specs have been upgraded to a sealed solenoid box and straight cut gears from previous years. Unless you actually work in the factory they are made in in china you can only go on what is told to us.

tigerz11 - your embarassing yourself coming out with that kind of statement, everyone is entitled to an opinion but you would look better writing down why you thought it was bull*&%$, but that would take some literacy now wouldnt it.

the problem is we have a bloke who asks a question of choice ,and he is expecting some advice ,he gets told they are made in the same factory ,,i then say thats crap ,or a word thats not approved ,,,BUT LET ME TELL YOU AGAIN THE T-MAX WINCH IS NOT MADE BY IN THE SAME FACTORY AS IRONMAN

[tna racing]

was speaking to a bloke that works for ironman. he wreckons there australian army tested wich means thats good.

we have a 9500lb ironman and its great.

[chpd80]

the problem is we have a bloke who asks a question of choice ,and he is expecting some advice ,he gets told they are made in the same factory ,,i then say thats crap ,or a word thats not approved ,,,BUT LET ME TELL YOU AGAIN THE T-MAX WINCH IS NOT MADE BY IN THE SAME FACTORY AS IRONMAN

So give the guy some advice You obviously have a very strong opinion on it. I couldnt really give a rats if I'm wrong about the same factory thing, thats just what the reps who sell them say. Its not about who is wrong or right, more just about what advice you can give someone,
just dont be such a tool about it.

[me3@neuralfibre.com]

I believe Tigerz gets over to China fairly frequently and deals with several manufacturers, so he should know what he is talking about what comes from where.

FYI: My ironman failed last trip - faulty weld on the drum.
I'll post my review next week with pics - stay tuned.

I like it, but it has failed 3 times now. (faulty lead from factory, switch doesn't like water, faulty weld on drum). There are no seals on the drum either.

I saw Tigerz winches and the internals and reckon they are better than the Ironman.

Catchya
Paul

[tna racing]

I believe Tigerz gets over to China fairly frequently and deals with several manufacturers, so he should know what he is talking about what comes from where.

FYI: My ironman failed last trip - faulty weld on the drum.
I'll post my review next week with pics - stay tuned.

I saw Tigerz winches and the internals and reckon they are better than the Ironman.

Catchya
Paul

i have a crappy quality video of our winch it did fine. and its a old one

[chpd80]

FYI: My ironman failed last trip - faulty weld on the drum.

Sorry to here that, was that the so called upgraded winch or an older model??? Look forward to seeing the pics.

[crazie]

Hi Guys

Having to go there about 6 times a year, I can tell you that they do not come out of the same factory. There are that many winch fatories in China, I know of at least 6 in the same city that we ( Ironman 4x4 ) have our facotry.

Paul, I would be keen to see where yours has broken, I havent seen a drum break yet. PM me if you want.

Cheers
Adam

[bogged]

I'll post my review next week with pics - stay tuned.

Oh I look foward to it so much, specially if it is as good as the winch mounting....

[tna racing]

I'll post my review next week with pics - stay tuned.

Oh I look foward to it so much, specially if it is as good as the winch mounting....

ever thought of making the mounting system stronger. i honestly think it broke due to too much FLEX in the PLATE

[crazie]

I believe Tigerz gets over to China fairly frequently and deals with several manufacturers, so he should know what he is talking about what comes from where.

FYI: My ironman failed last trip - faulty weld on the drum.
I'll post my review next week with pics - stay tuned.

I like it, but it has failed 3 times now. (faulty lead from factory, switch doesn't like water, faulty weld on drum). There are no seals on the drum either.

I saw Tigerz winches and the internals and reckon they are better than the Ironman.

Catchya
Paul

A quote from your other post.....
I tried to make it fail.

Ran out rope to last run on the drum.
Connected to tree uphill
Locked up Landcruiser with brakes and lockers and park
Attached Disco to landcruiser
Locked up Disco

Winched in
Mount twisted a little (I was watching it very closely)
Winch slowed
Cruiser Dragged
Strap between card came up tight
Winch slowed more
Technora (high temp) rope snapped where it was bent sharply over fairlead.
Mount showed no permanent deformation

It if breaks, it breaks

Assuming your winch is NOT mounted directly to your bar - anyone seen a strength or engineering analysis done on a metal plate mount?
Care to guess at the strength of the feet on the winch (they are alloy)
If the winch is sitting 250mm higher than the chassis rails, vs between them like this, that's a lot of twisting too. I frequently see bullbars movig up and down whilst winching, to spring back when done.

But yes, it's an experiment.

Paul

Hardly sounds like it failed under normal winch conditions.

Adam

[tna racing]

i agree there adam

[me3@neuralfibre.com]

I'll post my review next week with pics - stay tuned.

Oh I look foward to it so much, specially if it is as good as the winch mounting....
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

ever thought of making the mounting system stronger. i honestly think it broke due to too much FLEX in the PLATE

The pics are on http://picasaweb.google.com.au/adrenali ... hDrumFault

Seeing as I was only 3 ft from it, and watching it carefully, the mount is still perfect, and the winch is undamaged and works fine except for the weld, would you care to justify your obviously well thought out statement?

As I originally said - it's a fine winch, just some manufacturing gaps I think. Ironman's service has been good so far backing their product.

Forums are great, they let anyone demonstrate their intelligence.

Paul

[coopster]

thank for all that info it was good but confused about with one but all good

[tigerz11]

you wont go wrong with either,,the ironman has the new solenoid ,,i am not sure of the t-max,,the new type solenoid is a good way to go

[GQ WAGHOON]

How about buying a Tigerz11? How is 4WDTV going with theirs, and when are we going to see a story about it?

[GRPABT1]

I vote for the TMAX, I have one and it single line pulls to the last roll on the drum up some rediculous hills time after time, never had a drama with it.

I heard from here that they also have better/stronger gears than the Warn's which IMO are the most overrated piece of poo out there. My TMAX cost half the price of a warn and has faster line speed and is 500 pound higher rated.

[coopster]

i have seen the t max at a 4x4 store at Lansvale last week 4 $650

[pedr]

yeah just make sure the warn isnt warn out! ha ha get the pun?

[TEAMRPM]

Tigerz make a ripper of a winch, good value and work a treat.

mate brougt one and has no complaints. i was impressed.

ya just need to buy what suits your needs, he goes out not that often and couldn't justify warns prices. he got a winch less than half and had spare money for more accessories.


cheers

[turps]

Tigerz make a ripper of a winch, good value and work a treat.

mate brougt one and has no complaints. i was impressed.

ya just need to buy what suits your needs, he goes out not that often and couldn't justify warns prices. he got a winch less than half and had spare money for more accessories.


cheers

Now if Tigerz had posted some info like RPM has. He wouldnt look like a dick.
Thanks for the info about the factorys Crazie.