Posted: Tue Feb 14, 2006 10:14 am
Hi Bob,
The custom kit would undoubtetdly give better performance as long as you aren't too concerned about price! I would suggest that the custom kit would be quite a bit more expensive than the off-the-shelf kits.
The major difference between a kit and a custom job would be the manifold - typically these are cast iron, and are hardly tuned to perfection - they are just aimed at getting the exhuast gases into the turbine housing by whatever means possible. Tuned, matched length exhaust headers in a custom mandrel manifold would give you that slightly better performance. As would a mandrel bent exhaust matched to the turbine housing. The turbine housing itself should be sized to match the engine also - these factors will improve the spool up time of the turbine by increasing flow and reducing back pressure.
Once again, it really comes down to how much you want to spend and what sort of power gains you are looking for - regardless of boost, spool up times etc, they are just an afterthought.
For example, there are a few companies around who use standard Garrett turbochargers (one that springs to mind is developed around the T-27 core) with custom ordered housings / wheels - if you are happy with the performance gains of these relatively standard units, then it may be worth asking if they could special-order a GT27/28R frame with their housings and wheels, from there you could have the custom manifolds and pipework bent up to suit.
This involves:
- making / sourcing a custom exhaust manifold
- making / sourcing a custom aircleaner assembly (pressurizable / sealed)
- the compressor side suction and discharge pipes
- turbine dump housing and pipe
- pressurised oil & water lines
- adapters to suit engine block and turbocharger for oil & water
- sump modification for oil return
and optionally:
- intercooler installation
- oil cooler installation
If you are after more than the standard power gains (around 130FWHP peak +/-), then additional pump work and cooling become necessary, including fitment of an intercooler, and possibly oil cooler also. Achieving the goal of faster spool up and wider operating ranges also become slightly more challenging as the compressor map becomes tighter when selecting a t/c.
It is not too much of a problem to work out the best match turbo to your particular application - the key is *where* you want the compressors most efficient operating range to be (in terms of engine RPM / load)
Considering that the TD42's peak torque output is at 2000-2200rpm, I would suggest that this would be where you would want your efficiency to be. In calculating the compressor size, you would then need to consider where the effective stall limit is, and ensure this is below your required boost rpm start.
The custom kit would undoubtetdly give better performance as long as you aren't too concerned about price! I would suggest that the custom kit would be quite a bit more expensive than the off-the-shelf kits.
The major difference between a kit and a custom job would be the manifold - typically these are cast iron, and are hardly tuned to perfection - they are just aimed at getting the exhuast gases into the turbine housing by whatever means possible. Tuned, matched length exhaust headers in a custom mandrel manifold would give you that slightly better performance. As would a mandrel bent exhaust matched to the turbine housing. The turbine housing itself should be sized to match the engine also - these factors will improve the spool up time of the turbine by increasing flow and reducing back pressure.
Once again, it really comes down to how much you want to spend and what sort of power gains you are looking for - regardless of boost, spool up times etc, they are just an afterthought.
For example, there are a few companies around who use standard Garrett turbochargers (one that springs to mind is developed around the T-27 core) with custom ordered housings / wheels - if you are happy with the performance gains of these relatively standard units, then it may be worth asking if they could special-order a GT27/28R frame with their housings and wheels, from there you could have the custom manifolds and pipework bent up to suit.
This involves:
- making / sourcing a custom exhaust manifold
- making / sourcing a custom aircleaner assembly (pressurizable / sealed)
- the compressor side suction and discharge pipes
- turbine dump housing and pipe
- pressurised oil & water lines
- adapters to suit engine block and turbocharger for oil & water
- sump modification for oil return
and optionally:
- intercooler installation
- oil cooler installation
If you are after more than the standard power gains (around 130FWHP peak +/-), then additional pump work and cooling become necessary, including fitment of an intercooler, and possibly oil cooler also. Achieving the goal of faster spool up and wider operating ranges also become slightly more challenging as the compressor map becomes tighter when selecting a t/c.
It is not too much of a problem to work out the best match turbo to your particular application - the key is *where* you want the compressors most efficient operating range to be (in terms of engine RPM / load)
Considering that the TD42's peak torque output is at 2000-2200rpm, I would suggest that this would be where you would want your efficiency to be. In calculating the compressor size, you would then need to consider where the effective stall limit is, and ensure this is below your required boost rpm start.