Notice: We request that you don't just set up a new account at this time if you are a previous user.
If you used to be one of our moderators, please feel free to reach out to Chris via the facebook Outerlimits4x4 group and he will get you set back up with access should he need you.
Recovery:If you cannot access your old email address and don't remember your password, please click here to log a change of email address so you can do a password reset.

hmmm mog portals v's Volvo drop axles...

Tech Talk for Ford, Mazda, Daihatsu & Makes that currently dont have a home.

Moderator: Tiny

Posts: 1813
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2002 3:31 pm

Post by Strange Rover »

mud4b wrote:wow,for that sort of moola imagine the mods you could do to a normal diff.although i understand you still couldnt get that much clearance.


And even the mods you can do you will not get the similar sort of strength especially when you are talking steering axle strength.

To get something similar to a mog404 in a steering axle IMO you need to go to a d60 front with 300m shafts and joints which costs about $10 000 US (this is basically the axle that people run in rear steer US comp buggies)

You will never make any commonly available Aus steering 4wd axle anyway near as strong as a mog 404 axle. Even if you start looking at bigger truck axles you then start to have problems cause you carnt get a locker for them and low ground clearance.

To give you an idea of how strong my mog 404 axles my mog rover weighs 2.14 tonnes with a 302 Windsor V8 and 42in tyres and I drive it as absolutely as hard as I can with as much throttle as I can. Where talking second gear max revs launches in the rocks bouncing around while still holding it the throttle flat. And a couple of my mates even drive my rig harder than I do. And the thing still hasent broken.

I think that if these axles were in a normal 4wd with 35in tyres then you could never ever break them - no matter how hard you tried. Probably break transfer cases or something.

Sam
Posts: 11892
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:53 am
Location: Melbourne

Post by N*A*M »

mine...
Posts: 11892
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:53 am
Location: Melbourne

Post by N*A*M »

more...
Posts: 11892
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:53 am
Location: Melbourne

Post by N*A*M »

lastly...
Posts: 11892
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:53 am
Location: Melbourne

Post by N*A*M »

yes volvos will break well before a mog will break. but i would say they are stronger than your current diffs.

the birfield cvs are a weak spot compared to mogs; but compared to a standard diff, the portal gears theoretically halve the torque applied to the cv. this makes them more robust than standard cvs. the portal boxes themselves are cast and are pretty heavy duty. the diff housings are also fairly robust. don't forget that these are military axles. over built for abuse by grunts (ask singo how army equipment is used). the laplanders were also heavier than your average fourby, especially when loaded with equipment, munitions and personnel. these axles were built to work in those conditions, they will last on your rig. something may break but they will last.

the initial outlay will get you: increased strength, increase gearing reduction, dual lockers, increased clearance, possibly increased width (depending on your rig) - for front AND rear. now go buy a pair of longfields, HD custom axles for front and rear, lower diff ratios front and rear, arb lockers for front and rear, shave your housing front and rear for clearance. then see how much you have spent by that stage. probably more than you would have spent on volvos. you may be stronger but you'd still have less clearance. besides you wouldn't be able to match the diff ratio of 7.16:1 or even 6:1 and still retain strength in your diff centres. don't forget these volvos can still be beefed up. trussed housings, gun drilled chromo shafts, bigger treated cvs, etc...
Posts: 1575
Joined: Mon Oct 21, 2002 1:17 pm

Post by Singo17 »

N*A*M wrote:volvo-wise... we're talking about the c303 and c304 laplander.

probably started production in the sixties, fully retired from production in the eighties.

used by the swedish and malaysian armies. also some emergency agencies in europe used them too (fire, ambulance, rescue etc...)

diffs were produced by salisbury (related to spicer & dana), who also produced the rover diffs at the time. this explains the many parts commonalities.

good sources for diffs: US, europe, malaysia or australia (if you know the right people).

they are now rare and in high demand thus making them quite expensive. from malaysia, you're looking at over $14k for 3 sets shipped to australia.

mogs i know very little about.



Nam 14k for 3 sets mmmm Thats what $2300 each right what is for ARB lockers $3200 front and rear installed. So the diffs are really only about $700 a diff now. How much is a GU front 2nd hand or a Lux/cruiser with longs gonna set ya back.

See ya point Nam.

Wanna sell em :D
Official member of the Babinda Jimmy James Beam III Fan Club

Darth Bobo Honker Hunter Inc, for the up gunned Poodlefaker.

:armsup:"ARMS UP":armsup:
Posts: 1575
Joined: Mon Oct 21, 2002 1:17 pm

Post by Singo17 »

From Killeraxles.com


We stock used Unimog 404 axles.

401/411, 406 and U 1300 axles on request.

The price for a good used 404 steering axle is USD 1100

A non steering axle rear axle is USD 750

There would someone here who could calc the cast to get them here. But doesn't include pinion conversion etc.

Sam I also see your point.



On a side not anyone approach a Engineer about getting em Legal Nam I know you chatted outcome? :D
Official member of the Babinda Jimmy James Beam III Fan Club

Darth Bobo Honker Hunter Inc, for the up gunned Poodlefaker.

:armsup:"ARMS UP":armsup:
Posts: 11892
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:53 am
Location: Melbourne

Post by N*A*M »

From my conversations with Kevin Williams, Volvo portals are engineerable provided...

The chassis is deemed strong enough. Apparently, the Sierra chassis is not adequate but Hilux, Rangie, Cruiser, Patrol etc... is okay.

Steering box needs to be from a vehicle with similar weight to the Laplander. He said Patrol or Cruiser box is okay.

Drum brakes would be okay on a light to medium rig. Eg Suzuki, Hilux, Rangie. Just not big assed Patrols and Cruisers.

The width was okay as long as the tyres are covered as per regulations.

The factory 16x9 full backspaced rims were also okay.

He had no issues with the very low ratios and reduced maximum speed.

What killed my project was that the Suzuki chassis was not suitable, but it was possible to have it strengthened by a qualified chassis builder.

Obtaining engineering approval is very much a possibility if you play by their rules.
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:37 am
Location: Performing booty fab in my Garage

Post by Wooders »

Fawk even my puny Dana diffs have 5k invested in 'em....
some wanna nick it for me so I can start afresh ;)
And based on what NAM saying, I think a Jeep might have a chance of getting passed.....
Cheers [url=http://www.wooders.com.au]Wooders[/url]
Posts: 11892
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:53 am
Location: Melbourne

Post by N*A*M »

Speaking of Jeeps, if I could find a cheap TJ, that would be my ideal platform for a streetable portal'd rig. The frame has a very high arch for the axles and you could set one up to sit quite low to compensate for the portal height. I would have to find a tcase to suit though correct? The front output is passenger side though isn't it?
Posts: 3523
Joined: Sun May 18, 2003 8:42 pm
Location: Somewhere they can't reach me, shoot me or electrocute me...

Post by Area54 »

Just curious - what size tyre was originally supplied on the rigs the portals came off. Equivalent in inches.
Built, not bought.
Posts: 1575
Joined: Mon Oct 21, 2002 1:17 pm

Post by Singo17 »

N*A*M wrote:Speaking of Jeeps, if I could find a cheap TJ, that would be my ideal platform for a streetable portal'd rig. The frame has a very high arch for the axles and you could set one up to sit quite low to compensate for the portal height. I would have to find a tcase to suit though correct? The front output is passenger side though isn't it?


Nick Wooders.

Hell I'll do it you get the top bits :D i get the bottom bits :D
Official member of the Babinda Jimmy James Beam III Fan Club

Darth Bobo Honker Hunter Inc, for the up gunned Poodlefaker.

:armsup:"ARMS UP":armsup:
Posts: 11892
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:53 am
Location: Melbourne

Post by N*A*M »

Area54 wrote:Just curious - what size tyre was originally supplied on the rigs the portals came off. Equivalent in inches.


i would say 35" +/- 1"

search google for laplander and you'll see heaps of pics of stock trucks
Posts: 571
Joined: Tue Nov 19, 2002 3:56 pm
Location: New York

Post by zzzz »

N*A*M wrote:Speaking of Jeeps, if I could find a cheap TJ, that would be my ideal platform for a streetable portal'd rig. The frame has a very high arch for the axles and you could set one up to sit quite low to compensate for the portal height. I would have to find a tcase to suit though correct? The front output is passenger side though isn't it?


np321 - which is stock is passenger side front output as you mentioned.

dana300 is drivers side.
gear driven
cast
nearly as strong as an atlas
Cost is US$50-150 depending on condition.
then you need to ship one back here :)

Get started...
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:37 am
Location: Performing booty fab in my Garage

Post by Wooders »

Yup DEFFINATELY the Dana300 would be the pick of the "Jeep" transfer cases.
So where do we get these diffs from? & is the $5k the price for both diffs or just one???
Cheers [url=http://www.wooders.com.au]Wooders[/url]
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:37 am
Location: Performing booty fab in my Garage

Post by Wooders »

BTW NAM if you can get a hold of JP for 2 months ago they had a feature on a Portalled TJ....had stock springs and was running 40" tyres :shock: (with cutting etc).....
I was VERY impressed with the way it looked & the way it appeared to preform (in the pics)...I'll see if I can find an online link....
Cheers [url=http://www.wooders.com.au]Wooders[/url]
Posts: 1813
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2002 3:31 pm

Post by Strange Rover »

Area54 wrote:Just curious - what size tyre was originally supplied on the rigs the portals came off. Equivalent in inches.
]

Mog 404s have about a 40in tyre I think.

Sam
User avatar
POS
Posts: 4318
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:52 pm
Location: Perth

Post by POS »

mud4b wrote:wow,for that sort of moola imagine the mods you could do to a normal diff.although i understand you still couldnt get that much clearance.


Heres a broken down costing!

MOGS! = $5000.00 + Fitting and suspension! ($1000.00 Max)

You get Clearance, Strength (more than a D60), LOCKERS and Reduction (around 7:1)

A built up Hilux!

$250.00 front housing.
$500.00 High pinion 4.88 diff centre (strong)
$1500.00 ARB air locker
$1000.00 Longfields
$600.00 All-pro alloy inner axles!
$250.00 Wide track hilux rear housing and centre!
$1200.00 Arb Air locker
$1000.00 Either twin cases or reduction gears for t/case (to get to the same reduction as the mogs 7:1)
___________
$6300.00 :shock: :shock: :shock:

And you still have a pair of diffs that will take NO WHERE near the amount of abuse the MOGS will!
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:37 am
Location: Performing booty fab in my Garage

Post by Wooders »

Ok MOR questions....
The Mog 404 axle is 69/68" wide (f/r)...thats a lot more than a stock TJ with only 61"....
Asside from covering the tyres what other issues need to be addressed to permit the extra width??? Thinking road worth aspects only....
Cheers [url=http://www.wooders.com.au]Wooders[/url]
Posts: 384
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2002 8:26 pm
Location: Springfield/ QLD

Post by CJer »

Wooders you would have to move your fuel tank up into the cabin or go to a smaller tank and probly still have room issues :(
Posts: 683
Joined: Thu Mar 06, 2003 3:42 am
Location: Sydney

Post by GURU »

G'day all,

I agree that the Mog diffs are the ultimate, But I'm building a SWB defender using Range Rover diffs (which are weak as) and I was going to put maxi drives in, but for the same price i could get Mogs or Volvo's

I've liked the idea of the volvo's, because they are narrower than the mogs and abit easier to fit. So how much would a set of Volvo's with 7.19 ratio set me back?

And if the volvo's are really consider weak, how do they fair against a complete maxi drive diff ?
[i]DAS[/i]
MY05 4.4L V8 Range Rover Vogue
Series 2a Buggy....In the Building
Posts: 1813
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2002 3:31 pm

Post by Strange Rover »

DAS wrote:G'day all,

I agree that the Mog diffs are the ultimate, But I'm building a SWB defender using Range Rover diffs (which are weak as) and I was going to put maxi drives in, but for the same price i could get Mogs or Volvo's

I've liked the idea of the volvo's, because they are narrower than the mogs and abit easier to fit. So how much would a set of Volvo's with 7.19 ratio set me back?

And if the volvo's are really consider weak, how do they fair against a complete maxi drive diff ?


In the order of axle strenghts, im sorry to say that I think that maxi drive diff is way down the bottom of any aust axle. Nothing to do with maxi drive its just the rover crown wheel is very weak and the CVs arnt much better and the axle dia and spline count lets it down a bit also.

But anyway I would guess that a volvo c303 axle would be way stronger than a toy or nissan axle. I would say with a set of 37s and a decent v8 engine you would be doing well to break them.

When we say that the US guys break them they really are flogging the absolute piss out of them. Way harder than anybody you see in the Aust competitions.

The US guys break mog 404 axles as well.

Sam
Posts: 15549
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:23 am
Location: Your Mummas House!

Re: hmmm mog portals v's Volvo drop axles...

Post by bj on roids »

Punchy wrote:ok guys...

I was talking with the local 4x4 guy. I believe his name was mick at {enter plug}QLD 4x4 spares and repairs bogan street albion {end plug}
ANd we got talking about a few things about my 80 g/box issue and then we got started about sam's moggy and how i wouldn't mind doing something like that with my 75 series and all...

"Put vovlo diffs in it" was the reply..
"Hasn't been done before and you can get parts easier."

Sounds great idea to me, but how do these stack up against the mogs for strength and comparison

Any mog boys got some ideas ?

why did you use mog diffs over volvo's ?


i got pictures of a mid wheelbase 75 series with volvo axles and pics of lots of forty series and even a series 1 landrover!

yeah the volvos have been done......
Last edited by bj on roids on Wed Sep 03, 2003 8:27 am, edited 1 time in total.
hands and mums dont count!!!
Posts: 4065
Joined: Thu Oct 24, 2002 8:31 am
Location: ACT

Post by Wendle »

My friend is still trying to sell mog 404 axles fpr $4000 a pair if you are interested..

The volvo axles would have to be the perfect compromise for a registered truck though...
Posts: 15549
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:23 am
Location: Your Mummas House!

Post by bj on roids »

antt wrote:
RUFF wrote:And here is a pic of his spare Diff Collection :D

You can never have too many diffs to choose from :D


sam, you must have a bloody good security setup to keep all these other boys away from your spare mogs down at bootie central. i bet they'd be itching to get em under their rigs :D


Sam said if i can lif tthe dana 60 myself and put it on my ute i can take it home for free. After i tried and my spleen shot out my bumcrack i grabbed my spleen and did the bolt!
hands and mums dont count!!!
Posts: 15549
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 9:23 am
Location: Your Mummas House!

Post by bj on roids »

bj on roids wrote:
antt wrote:
RUFF wrote:And here is a pic of his spare Diff Collection :D

You can never have too many diffs to choose from :D


sam, you must have a bloody good security setup to keep all these other boys away from your spare mogs down at bootie central. i bet they'd be itching to get em under their rigs :D


Sam said if i can lif tthe dana 60 myself and put it on my ute i can take it home for free. After i tried and my spleen shot out my bumcrack i grabbed my spleen and did the bolt!


the security is also second to none, he has three big attack/guard dogs. Those things will tear your arm off! (im not talking about rod, im talking about the dogs)
hands and mums dont count!!!
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:37 am
Location: Performing booty fab in my Garage

Post by Wooders »

N*A*M wrote:wms width = 176cm (they run fully backspaced 16x9 rims).


176cm = 69" .....that's the same as a Mog 404 front & 1" more than a 404 rear.....??
Seems the pinion length is a BIG issue with the mogs....
Sam, do you have the stock pinion length or is it converted? Was this a big factor in your extended wheelbase?
Is the Volvo pinion smaller?
Where to get some dimensions & sh!t???

I've long been toying with the idea of dual D60's but seems This could be a cheaper (stronger) option so I'm keen to fully investigate it.....
As for the fuel tank - I cnsider that one of the smaller issues in getting it to work since I've be talking at least a new t/case and exhaust system too....
Cheers [url=http://www.wooders.com.au]Wooders[/url]
Posts: 1813
Joined: Sun Oct 20, 2002 3:31 pm

Post by Strange Rover »

Wooders wrote:
N*A*M wrote:wms width = 176cm (they run fully backspaced 16x9 rims).


176cm = 69" .....that's the same as a Mog 404 front & 1" more than a 404 rear.....??
Seems the pinion length is a BIG issue with the mogs....
Sam, do you have the stock pinion length or is it converted? Was this a big factor in your extended wheelbase?
Is the Volvo pinion smaller?
Where to get some dimensions & sh!t???

I've long been toying with the idea of dual D60's but seems This could be a cheaper (stronger) option so I'm keen to fully investigate it.....
As for the fuel tank - I cnsider that one of the smaller issues in getting it to work since I've be talking at least a new t/case and exhaust system too....


I have done a "pinion conversion" and all this does is give you a normal pinion flange on the pinion shaft to bolt a normal tailshaft to (as opposed to the torque tube arrangement they come with standard). The pinion is still very long.

Nah - I wanted this wheelbase anyway. I would guess I could have gone as short as say 104in .... possibly shorter.

Sam
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:37 am
Location: Performing booty fab in my Garage

Post by Wooders »

OK thanks - I was under the mis-impression that it actually gave you a shorter pinion....and as I see it the rear driveshaft length (or lack of) is potentially one of the bigger issues with a TJ....104"WB is 11" more than mine is now :? (stock it's 91")
Cheers [url=http://www.wooders.com.au]Wooders[/url]
Posts: 1544
Joined: Tue Oct 22, 2002 8:37 am
Location: Performing booty fab in my Garage

Post by Wooders »

BTW just to prove it's doable - here's the Moggler TJ...
Image
Image
Image
Cheers [url=http://www.wooders.com.au]Wooders[/url]
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests