Page 3 of 5
Posted: Thu Apr 17, 2008 2:11 pm
by toughnut
coxy321 wrote:Sort of, but i dont agree 100%. Then you would have to take into concideration things like different electrical cabling, different charging systems (alternators), winch pulling height (whether one is higher or lower than the other), and if the winching vehicle isnt anchored then suspension/tyres/vehicle weight have to be looked at.
Coxy
Not really. Cables are part of the kit. Use the same batteries and do a dead pull so you don't need to take into account the alternator.
Posted: Thu Apr 17, 2008 2:11 pm
by macca81
flexytj wrote:lets bet on this
im backing the tigerz11 as a dark horse to win
X2. what odds?
Posted: Thu Apr 17, 2008 2:42 pm
by Zac Zec
I am waiting for the winch off and i am sure others are to. If tigerz is as good as said i will go straight out and buy one as i am sure others will to.
Sooner or later the chinese are going to either force warn to china (if not all ready) or if not anything else force their prices down.
They are for ever getting better.
my 2c
Posted: Thu Apr 17, 2008 3:16 pm
by coxy321
toughnut wrote:Not really. Cables are part of the kit. Use the same batteries and do a dead pull so you don't need to take into account the alternator.
My apologies - i should have been more detailed. I was reffering to alternator cabling, earth straps etc. Vehicle cabling, not winch cabling.
Coxy
Posted: Thu Apr 17, 2008 6:58 pm
by tigerz11
whos running the winch off ??
sunday
Posted: Thu Apr 17, 2008 11:50 pm
by Hobzee
Winch Off Details ...
Was schedulled for 12 noon but I have #1 son playing football and #1 wife is bed ridden and I have to take him. I've been told. Can we make it for 4pm at all? On Saturday I am driving interstate to pick up a "parts car". Good thing the missus is in bed - what she can't see wont hurt her.
I think people coming will have open minds and keen to see up close what the likes of Iron Man, Tiger and Warn and anything else have to offer. If Tiger has a good product then I will stand by it. I know ironman is good and already stand by their products. I'd rather this not be a competition or "show down" but rather a network/workshop field day type thing on winches - who knows, maybe this will lead into a truly professional field day modelled on specific product types.
Address 1300 Frankston Flinders Rd Somerville Vic.
4PM this sunday.
Mob 0417 486 637.
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 6:55 am
by tigerz11
Hello All
I am prepaid send send a new winch down but its not going to arrive in time.
Also i have heard that in china there are factories attempting to make either a 15000lb/16800lb 12v low mount winch ,when i talk low mount i mean to fit in the ARB and TJM bars and so so,,,the company i deal with say it cant be done successfully ,,,,there concerns were the drum size not being able to carry enough rope they say max 18metres,,,the company i deal with do have a 13000lb low mount winch that dimensionally will fit in the ARB bars ,,,any thoughts on this
regards all
size
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 7:27 am
by Hobzee
Something like 18,000 pound would sell but agreed size will hold it back - I have the same problem with the BOSS compressor - bigger and better than any other 12V compressor (no doubt) but hard to find a place to put it. I think 12,000 is already bigger than most people need - I can see a stronger winch reefing bull bars off cars and causing other problems.
I think if you sell the winch on its strengths and spend less time worrying about the competition you would do just fine. The market is so big there can be several winners.
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 8:40 am
by tigerz11
Agreed and done
Re: sunday
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 8:44 am
by coxy321
Hobzee wrote:Address 1300 Frankston Flinders Rd Somerville Vic.
4PM this sunday.
Hhmmm, thats way down near the ar$ehole of nowhere...... not too sure if i can swaggle the 4hr drive down and back.....
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 1:42 pm
by tna racing
NavRun wrote:I'm with you Hobzee- I will be Judge , Jury and Executioneer.
Tiger winch dudes are making big calls with their winches!!!!! Up against a WARN????????????
our iron man out pulls any chinese winch
weve had a ironman winch for 3 years. been used pleanty of times. imho its no different to my thomas in the shed. for the fact it was better. thats why the thomas is in the shed
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 1:47 pm
by tigerz11
tna racing wrote:NavRun wrote:I'm with you Hobzee- I will be Judge , Jury and Executioneer.
Tiger winch dudes are making big calls with their winches!!!!! Up against a WARN????????????
i would be in on that. our iron man out pulls any chinese winch
who said anything about being better than warn,,,and where do you think ironman is maufactured!
Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2008 7:23 pm
by Reddo
hey, anyone bought a Warn lately? I just did - XP9.5 after a lot of research.
Pulling it apart it sure looks well made, but the sealing is not as good as I thought it would be. I'll have to fix that myself.
Interstingly, "Made in China" appears on several bits and pieces, and nowhere does it say "Made in USA" or wherever it is actually made - I've got to suspect China given that is what is stated on several packagings......Warn web site is silent too - how convenient:)
Guess we'll have to get used to Chinese for everything, at least until there's a cheaper place to make things and fatten profits (Cambodia anyone), including fridges and washing machines.
My advice, get over it, I have even though it cost me nearly 2 K for the most recent pleasure (read pain) of finding "made in china" where I least expected too:(
Hum......
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 9:33 am
by Hamo
See ya at 4.00pm for the show down (demo)
Any one else coming with a tigerz?
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 6:58 pm
by Corgie Carrier
How did the winch demo go?
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 7:01 pm
by tna racing
Corgie Carrier wrote:How did the winch demo go?
x20000
come on
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 8:48 pm
by hjgq
Howed the winch off go it's been 4 hours need results!!
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 9:22 pm
by Hamo
Well i guess i won the low mount test with the tigerz (by default)
as nobody else turned up
and hobzee beat me with his comp high mount and i burnt out my motor trying to keep up.
Maybe tigerz can give me a new winch for my effort
now not wanting to get into a debate about who's winch is better
be it a warn Ironman tigerz repco or even the aldi in a low mount
I can only comment on the tigerz
This is a good winch for those starting out 4wdriving it has saved my butt twice and i have rescued a hilux that was stuck in a bog hole (big time)
if i had to get in a tow truck to rescue me on those two occasions it whould cost me more than what i had paid for the winch
So for those who want to buy a low mount buy whatever one that has the longest warranty
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 9:30 pm
by tigerz11
hamo
well done for having the balls to show up and having a crack ,,yes i will replace your winch,,with a new one
regards tigerz11
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 9:36 pm
by sclarke7171
Can i come with my 80's built 8000lb warn Low mount???
Still got its orig cable and only used less than 10 times in its life....
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 9:50 pm
by Hamo
sclarke7171 wrote:Can i come with my 80's built 8000lb warn Low mount???
Still got its orig cable and only used less than 10 times in its life....
You can come if you have a time machine as it was all over red rover about 5 hours ago
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:02 pm
by Hobzee
tigerz11 wrote:hamo
well done for having the balls to show up and having a crack ,,yes i will replace your winch,,with a new one
regards tigerz11
Nice one Tigerz11... You da man ...
Hamo started with a SWB FJ40. It is now a Troopy.
I would like to organise a proper workshop demonstration in a more scientific environment and invite all winch companies and winch modification companies and advertsie it in mags, clubs, etc. We would compare strength, speed, current draw, price, warranty, available parts, etc. Given that most interested people wont be comp rigs then speed is less of a concern and we would be more after a pulling power output to current draw ratio. If we could get almost every brand there and the dudes such as Smithy, Flamin and Mal Leslie we would have quite a comprehensive line up and be an occassion worth attending.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:03 pm
by Hamo
tigerz11 wrote:hamo
well done for having the balls to show up and having a crack ,,yes i will replace your winch,,with a new one
regards tigerz11
Well it apears tigerz11 want's to exchange my winch for a new one not just replace it for my effort.
i was going to get my old one repaired for my son to put on his shorty 40
i guess i just repair this one for myself and not bother to stick up for and plug his winch anymore
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:11 pm
by tigerz11
Hamo wrote:tigerz11 wrote:hamo
well done for having the balls to show up and having a crack ,,yes i will replace your winch,,with a new one
regards tigerz11
Well it apears tigerz11 want's to exchange my winch for a new one not just replace it for my effort.
i was going to get my old one repaired for my son to put on his shorty 40
i guess i just repair this one for myself and not bother to stick up for and plug his winch anymore
you ungrateful bloke,,,i will replace your 3 year winch for a brand new one ,,,BUT NO YOU WANT MORE ,,what a joke
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:35 pm
by rockcrawler31
that just got a bit weird
i hope that was a typo hamo, because if not then it looks like you're knocking back the offer of a Brand spanking new winch, where before all of this you had a used winch.
so for the time and expense of going to a winch vs winch challenge you get your winch updated to a new one......sounds like a good deal to me.
doesn't make you look all that good.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:41 pm
by Cossie
tigerz11 wrote:Hamo wrote:tigerz11 wrote:hamo
well done for having the balls to show up and having a crack ,,yes i will replace your winch,,with a new one
regards tigerz11
Well it apears tigerz11 want's to exchange my winch for a new one not just replace it for my effort.
i was going to get my old one repaired for my son to put on his shorty 40
i guess i just repair this one for myself and not bother to stick up for and plug his winch anymore
you ungrateful bloke,,,i will replace your 3 year winch for a brand new one ,,,BUT NO YOU WANT MORE ,,what a joke
Tell him to jam it up his ass. Ungrateful bastard doesn't deserve it.
I have to ask though - what happened, did the motor burn out? under what circumstances? Is it likely to have happened during a real recovery situation?
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:43 pm
by sclarke7171
I was thinking the same thing, i read it 4 times and it seams that HAMO does not want a NEW WINCH...
Can i have it instead..........
I'll give you my old W8000 Warn....
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:45 pm
by coxy321
rockcrawler31 wrote:that just got a bit weird
i hope that was a typo hamo, because if not then it looks like you're knocking back the offer of a Brand spanking new winch, where before all of this you had a used winch.
so for the time and expense of going to a winch vs winch challenge you get your winch updated to a new one......sounds like a good deal to me.
doesn't make you look all that good.
x2
I was going to give props to tigerz11 for a) standing behind his product; and b) offering to completely replace and old banger winch for a new one.
Did we miss something?? It doesn't sound right....
Coxy
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 6:56 pm
by RUFF
tigerz11 wrote:Hamo wrote:tigerz11 wrote:hamo
well done for having the balls to show up and having a crack ,,yes i will replace your winch,,with a new one
regards tigerz11
Well it apears tigerz11 want's to exchange my winch for a new one not just replace it for my effort.
i was going to get my old one repaired for my son to put on his shorty 40
i guess i just repair this one for myself and not bother to stick up for and plug his winch anymore
you ungrateful bloke,,,i will replace your 3 year winch for a brand new one ,,,BUT NO YOU WANT MORE ,,what a joke
I agrea. Your an Asshole Hamo
. I hope you get stuck somewhere and no one bothers to help you out.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 7:16 pm
by bazooked
hamo u must be retarded, and i hope it rains elephant shit when ur out bush next.