Page 1 of 2

Anyone Regret Getting a rear Locker (Losing LSD)

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 9:25 am
by noodle
Thinking about getting a rear air locker to compliment the front.
Anyone done this and regret losing their LSD?, is it that noticeable when driving ?

Not really keen on Auto Lockers

Re: Anyone Regret Getting a rear Locker (Losing LSD)

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 9:31 am
by danny40
noodle wrote:Thinking about getting a rear air locker to compliment the front.
Anyone done this and regret losing their LSD?, is it that noticeable when driving ?

Not really keen on Auto Lockers
wouldnt the lsd function normally untill you engage the air locker? or do they remove the lsd to fit a airlocker?

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 9:40 am
by *cruiser*
The LSD is removed to fit the air locker ! Dont regret having the air locker in the rear at all. Yes and they are much better than the auto lockers as you can turn them on and off when needed. But the auto lockers do work well as a locker !! Go the air locker in the rear you will not regret it!!!!!!!!!!

Cheers
Shane

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 10:51 am
by Reddo
nope, always loved the airlocker never regretted having one

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 12:00 pm
by weeman
I actually do miss my LSD, mind you upgraded to an AIRlocker because i blew my LSD apart.

If you have lots of power at the rear wheels, you have to sometimes have to engage the locker whilist driving, i noticed i have to do this in the wet, or slippery areas otherwise i single spin and thats not good to do in an air locker...

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 12:47 pm
by bogged
weeman wrote:I actually do miss my LSD
If you have lots of power at the rear wheels...
what he said. I did miss LSD in GQ.. single spinner sucks arse in wet.

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 1:16 pm
by Red Dog 4x4
I wouldn't think twice about putting a locker in, LSD are S|-|!t, go the locker, if you can't drive with out a lsd on the road don't drive..... :D

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 2:20 pm
by noodle
Thanks for your feedback.

The trucks mainly used for weekends now anyway so locker it is :cool:

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 3:32 pm
by steel
Yeah i missed having a LSD on road ( when my ute was a daily driver )

Also much prefer LSD in super soft sand

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 3:33 pm
by nzdarin
I am in the process of pulling my rear locker out and putting the LSD back in. I find with the locker that it either pushs straight ahead or slides. It makes the handling much less refinded and uncontrolable at speed. At low speed in the dry it is great but in the wet with power it sucks. I have to have it in or one wheel just lights up and you go nowhere and then with it in it either won't turn or it slides.
The worst thing I ever did was fit the rear locker.
Sure my truck isn't really standard and has a lot more hp than most and I've done many years with rear LSD and front locker so that is what I was use to but after 3 comps with the rear locker you can keep them.

For going slow in the dry then they are great but if wet you don't need it and if going fast they make the truck twichy and unpredictable.

My opinion is rear LSD and front air locker is by far the best combination. That is based on using the same truck with rear LSD and rear locker and wih front locker. So it is a pretty good comparison.

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 3:43 pm
by bogged
nzdarin wrote:but after 3 comps with the rear locker you can keep them. .
I'll send you my address to post it too.... ;)

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 3:55 pm
by Red Dog 4x4
I am in the process of pulling my rear locker out and putting the LSD back in. I find with the locker that it either pushs straight ahead or slides. It makes the handling much less refinded and uncontrolable at speed. At low speed in the dry it is great but in the wet with power it sucks. I have to have it in or one wheel just lights up and you go nowhere and then with it in it either won't turn or it slides.
The worst thing I ever did was fit the rear locker.
Sure my truck isn't really standard and has a lot more hp than most and I've done many years with rear LSD and front locker so that is what I was use to but after 3 comps with the rear locker you can keep them.

For going slow in the dry then they are great but if wet you don't need it and if going fast they make the truck twichy and unpredictable.

My opinion is rear LSD and front air locker is by far the best combination. That is based on using the same truck with rear LSD and rear locker and wih front locker. So it is a pretty good comparison.
All i can say is NZ conditons, and comps are a lot diffrent to aussy comps and conditions, so it dose make it hard to compair the too. Just my 2cents worth.....

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 4:00 pm
by stressed
just put mine in and can not notice the diffcent but still earty

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 4:45 pm
by AFeral
Love my locker, I do miss my lsd rear end, mine was in good condition and made a differance. Had a few people say ' you drove that easy because you got lockers' The look on there face when I told them i did'nt was priceless. Even had one guy have a look for the locker switchs.

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 4:55 pm
by money_killer
no questions asked locker all the way. but if i had a daily i would not put an auto locker in it. air is the go. :cool:

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 5:00 pm
by vanbox
Does also depend on the quality/construction of the LSD. Some are better than others and some may as well be an open centre.

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 5:04 pm
by LOCKEE
Agree,

love the locker but miss the drivability of LSD. If had to start over would have a Detroit built or even consider shimming up rear LSD.

I lock the rear end up all the time when in 4WD. Only have to unlock occasionally. Must be so many Rover experiences and locking centre diff etc.

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 8:08 pm
by gqpete
Red Dog 4x4 wrote:I wouldn't think twice about putting a locker in, LSD are S|-|!t, go the locker, if you can't drive with out a lsd on the road don't drive..... :D
we won rnd 1 engel with a stock gq rear lsd. won by 100 pnts. :D
my vote LSD

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 8:39 pm
by GUte
I run the Air Locker in the front.
The LSD in the rear, shimmed tight, but not too tight that it would squeel on bitumen.
I find this combo works great.

Al.

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 11:25 pm
by noodle
so to the guys who have shimmed their LSD how much is too much ??
I drive a GU Coil Cab with 150 000 on the clock

Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 11:44 pm
by Mario
I've got a shimmed LSD in front. Worked as a spool for 5 or 6 trips then started loosening. Still is better than being open. On the rear diff. I've got an air locker. One of the best upgrades. Don't regret at all.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 1:28 am
by sudso
Manual Locker!!! Even though Patrol LSD's are one of the best you'll still only get up to 40% of reduced wheel spin at the wheel with the least traction.
Got a factory locker in mine and would never get an auto locker.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 9:26 am
by nzdarin
Red Dog 4x4 wrote:
I am in the process of pulling my rear locker out and putting the LSD back in. I find with the locker that it either pushs straight ahead or slides. It makes the handling much less refinded and uncontrolable at speed. At low speed in the dry it is great but in the wet with power it sucks. I have to have it in or one wheel just lights up and you go nowhere and then with it in it either won't turn or it slides.
The worst thing I ever did was fit the rear locker.
Sure my truck isn't really standard and has a lot more hp than most and I've done many years with rear LSD and front locker so that is what I was use to but after 3 comps with the rear locker you can keep them.

For going slow in the dry then they are great but if wet you don't need it and if going fast they make the truck twichy and unpredictable.

My opinion is rear LSD and front air locker is by far the best combination. That is based on using the same truck with rear LSD and rear locker and wih front locker. So it is a pretty good comparison.
All i can say is NZ conditons, and comps are a lot diffrent to aussy comps and conditions, so it dose make it hard to compair the too. Just my 2cents worth.....
I agree totally and that is why I tried to make the coments re dry conditions vs wet mud. ie Dry the locker is better but wet I hate it.

Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 2:28 pm
by 1TUFFGQ
ALso the other downside, which would rarely occur, is the compressor failing or an airline blowing out = c#$t of atime getting out of a hard section like that.

Posted: Fri May 08, 2009 8:58 pm
by patrol man
I don't miss the LSD, there is nothing better than air lockers!
I shimmed up my LSD, it was good but the first time I over did it ( I had to put it in the press to get it back together ). It was nearly a full locker but as it wore in, it would clunk like all hell. I then fitted a smaller shim, it was good but would let me down when rock crawling. from there I got a air locker to match the front. I do notice the inner wheel pick up on corners on the road in the wet, but it is better that when it would kick out sideways due to the LSD.
I have had times when the air lockers have let me down , mainly due to a stick ripping out an air line, like the time I was coming down a hill rutted to the shxx, taking the high side, lockers on, noticed the compressor start up and saw the air gauge dropping, lost both lockers slid sideways and came real close to a roll over. I'm a bit more clued on now, so when it happens I am able to shut down the leaking locker quickly, but still it is a pain in the xxx when it happens, the upgrade air line kit would probably fix this , something I am yet to do.
all in all , air lockers all the way!

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 12:24 pm
by bigbluemav
Nope never! When I had the Mav' I drove it the same way I do the GU now. On road I noticed no difference because I drive it like the TRUCK it is, and off road, I only engaged it when I felt it would be needed.

Go the Air Locker and as long as your not doing high speed comp work off road or racing drifters on road ( :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: ) you'll find it the best decision you've made.

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 12:40 pm
by jet-6
nzdarin wrote:I am in the process of pulling my rear locker out and putting the LSD back in. I find with the locker that it either pushs straight ahead or slides. It makes the handling much less refinded and uncontrolable at speed. At low speed in the dry it is great but in the wet with power it sucks. I have to have it in or one wheel just lights up and you go nowhere and then with it in it either won't turn or it slides.
The worst thing I ever did was fit the rear locker.
Sure my truck isn't really standard and has a lot more hp than most and I've done many years with rear LSD and front locker so that is what I was use to but after 3 comps with the rear locker you can keep them.

For going slow in the dry then they are great but if wet you don't need it and if going fast they make the truck twichy and unpredictable.

My opinion is rear LSD and front air locker is by far the best combination. That is based on using the same truck with rear LSD and rear locker and wih front locker. So it is a pretty good comparison.

I have a as new rear LSD spare, wanna swap

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 7:19 pm
by nzdarin
The freight would be a killer and I already have a spare LSD sitting here!

Posted: Sun May 10, 2009 7:53 pm
by jet-6
Yer, forgot to look where you were, A LSD to NZ would be around $92AUD

Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 9:52 am
by NutterGQ
Red Dog 4x4 wrote:I wouldn't think twice about putting a locker in, LSD are S|-|!t, go the locker, if you can't drive with out a lsd on the road don't drive..... :D
My car spins 4th gear in the wet on my 31s and 35s.....so u rekon it would be easy with an open diff...lol maybe if it was a 35rwkw model u could make such a comment, but we don't all drive shlt boxes and need more drive on road too