Page 1 of 1

Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Sat Mar 24, 2012 10:01 pm
by MazdaSpater
Does anyone have any experience with "Sonny", "Achilles Desert Hawk", "Goodride", or "Westlake" Budget muddies?
I am chasing some budget 31's and I am in Canberra, everything cheap is in Sydney and I cant see it from here.

$850 with rims seems too good to be true for four. Is it?

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Sat Mar 24, 2012 10:04 pm
by flyinwall
i had Achilles Desert Hawk H/T on my old terrano (they were on it when i got it) and they were a good tyre and i have seen the M/T version and they look quite good as well

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 6:55 pm
by flexytj
get federals . they are a touch dearer but alot better than any of those

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 7:07 pm
by azwa
goodrides are on my camper just cheap tyres but seem to have great wear i wouldnt run em on the 4b tho ...
if ya want cheap muddies just look for a 2nd hand set $500 will get ya sorted

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Sun Mar 25, 2012 10:45 pm
by Skegbudley
flexytj wrote:get federals . they are a touch dearer but alot better than any of those
X2 on the Federals.
Nice and aggressive for offroad andhave decent road holding. Even in the wet.

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Mon Mar 26, 2012 3:59 am
by azwa
Skegbudley wrote:
flexytj wrote:get federals . they are a touch dearer but alot better than any of those
X2 on the Federals.
Nice and aggressive for offroad andhave decent road holding. Even in the wet.

x3 couragia cheap at $260 a tyre you cant go wrong...

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Mon Mar 26, 2012 9:29 am
by Guy
The "sonny" ones have had some not bad write ups in afew european mags.. I am considering a set as well .. I can go six for less than the price of 4 big brand units.

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2012 7:47 am
by RockyF75
azwa wrote:
Skegbudley wrote:
flexytj wrote:get federals . they are a touch dearer but alot better than any of those
X2 on the Federals.
Nice and aggressive for offroad andhave decent road holding. Even in the wet.

x3 couragia cheap at $260 a tyre you cant go wrong...
I got maxxis bighorns for around that price :?

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Wed Mar 28, 2012 8:03 am
by evanstaniland
I'm running khumo muds, 275/75/16 they were $270, can't fault them, aggressive pattern, quiet on road seem to be wearing well, clean mud out well!

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 7:38 pm
by Evil!
azwa wrote:
Skegbudley wrote:
flexytj wrote:get federals . they are a touch dearer but alot better than any of those
X2 on the Federals.
Nice and aggressive for offroad andhave decent road holding. Even in the wet.
x3 couragia cheap at $260 a tyre you cant go wrong...
x4 had them in a 31 and a 33 then went to 35 creepy crawlers but if i am short on cash and need new tires im going feds again.
260? wow i payed 220 fitted for 33x12.5.15's and 280 for 35's lol

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 7:40 am
by azwa
Evil! wrote:
azwa wrote:
Skegbudley wrote:
flexytj wrote:get federals . they are a touch dearer but alot better than any of those
X2 on the Federals.
Nice and aggressive for offroad andhave decent road holding. Even in the wet.
x3 couragia cheap at $260 a tyre you cant go wrong...
x4 had them in a 31 and a 33 then went to 35 creepy crawlers but if i am short on cash and need new tires im going feds again.
260? wow i payed 220 fitted for 33x12.5.15's and 280 for 35's lol

yeah mate i payed $1200 for 5 on sunnys in a 33" (285 75 16) , $260 is the dearest ive seen em for...
same with the bighorns $300 each for 35" (315 75 16) ... i think the federals work better but horses for courses...

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 10:11 am
by Skegbudley
The Federals are better in mud than the Bighorns.
I find that the Bighorns are more refined and are a better overall tyre.

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 3:52 pm
by flyinwall
azwa wrote:

x3 couragia cheap at $260 a tyre you cant go wrong...
i got 33x12.5x15 mickey thompsons mtz's for that price

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 5:42 pm
by azwa
flyinwall wrote:
azwa wrote:

x3 couragia cheap at $260 a tyre you cant go wrong...
i got 33x12.5x15 mickey thompsons mtz's for that price

15's not 16's .... mtz's arent much chop mate id take the couragia's over em anyday...

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 6:04 pm
by flyinwall
so would i now that i know they are NOT worth the money i payed for them and i would happily go back to the maxxis big horns that i had (they were a much better tyre)

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2012 7:15 pm
by azwa
flyinwall wrote:so would i now that i know they are NOT worth the money i payed for them and i would happily go back to the maxxis big horns that i had (they were a much better tyre)

mate weve all thrown away coin to learn what road we need to go down ...
i agree the bighorns have great wear in comparison to mtz's...
but im now runnin km2's so ill see how they go...

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Wed Apr 04, 2012 10:42 pm
by dizzle
Never heard of those tyres, so i wouldnt touch them.
Sounds like everyone likes the federals which is good cause i just bought a set. See how they go. Tough looking tyre!

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Thu Apr 05, 2012 9:37 pm
by XXL_45L_CRUISER
my thoughts here,bighorns were a good allrounder type tyre,federals good bang for your buck,looked good went good on and off road but i found in the wet they wernt to good,km2s are what i run now and there amazing!!

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Fri Apr 13, 2012 1:17 pm
by 4_low
Another Vote for the Federals, i have had them on my weekender now for 3 years and cant fault them, the only reason im not running them anymore is i got a set of 35" creep crawlers.

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2012 6:58 am
by Mudpig4x4
Running federal couragia 35s... Awsome road grip in wet and good off road self clean really easy. noisy on road but what do u expect for an aggressive muddie

Re: Cheap muddies, Anyone used them?

Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2012 7:34 am
by pigletracing
azwa wrote:
flyinwall wrote:so would i now that i know they are NOT worth the money i payed for them and i would happily go back to the maxxis big horns that i had (they were a much better tyre)

mate weve all thrown away coin to learn what road we need to go down ...
i agree the bighorns have great wear in comparison to mtz's...
but im now runnin km2's so ill see how they go...

Ive run Micky T Claw Radials , MTZ muds & ATZ 4 ribs (allterain) & Im now running Maxxis Big horns.
All the aggressive mud tyres wore much similar on the road (providing I rotated & balanced every 5000klm & averaged around the 45 to 50 thousand klm before retiring them.
The ATZ 4 rib did 90 thousand, I found them great on road & nearly as good as MTZ & bighorn mud terains off road.
As I said, I am currently running Bighorns & I wont run them again, but I will go back to ATZ 4 rib.