Page 1 of 1
I have a 40 do i go a petrol or diesel motor
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 3:47 am
by Iava64/40
I have a 40 that I am rebuilding and have to decide petrol or diesel motor. It had no motor with it but it had a 3-speed gearbox and transfer case. What do you think will be the best motor? (The old motor was petrol and I half expect to do changes to the box tc diff and so on.)
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 3:58 am
by De-lux
go a diesel.
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 7:55 am
by Busiboy
Hi power diesel but bigger $
5lt petrol cheap plus good power
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 4:44 pm
by plowy
A 14bt diesel import motor it is a yota motor 4cyl ,3.7ltr with a factory turbo around the $5000 /6500 same physical size as a 3b in wich is only 3.4ltr none turbo.Then u can go in the water with out uppsettin the dizzy and all the rest of the wet petrol probs . The 14bt also has a shit load more power than the 1hz even if its turbed
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 6:31 pm
by Busiboy
That is a crap load of money to spend on a 40!!
If I do my maths I have only spent, carry the 3 ummmm
Go ahead sound cheap to me
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 7:02 pm
by scotto
Busiboy wrote:That is a crap load of money to spend on a 40!!
but dude ITS A 40
my std boring old 3b is a tractor at the best of times but it never complains when its wet, it revs real low, doesn't overheat, doesn't stall on steep stuff.....
i have seen many a petrol including v8s fall victim to water and angles
UNLESS they are EFI/or on gas only this is where the pretol engine set up price curve seems to rise. do you see much mud or water?
i am looking at efi holden v6/v8 - compared to turbomacating my 250,000k diesel (straight through 3"breathing, "conservative boost" ).
at similar money its a tough choice cause rebuilding my old diesel down the track could cost me a bomb...the question for me is do i want to risk that outlay twice by sticking to diesel? (cause i love it!!)
ball tearing power could be fun
ask yourself what your budget is
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 7:50 pm
by plowy
Ive replaced my old 3b with another 3b in the interest of originality[dam fool for doing that] i was suggested the 14bt buy a mate who runs it in a dual cab dyna on 60 series running gear at 10psi wich halls arse big time, but i didn't listen [again dam fool ] even tho the 3b has 4500km on it if i had the money id convert to the 14bt ,yep ive spent to much on it so i may as well keep goin n increase the national debt on it . Havent decided if its love or a sickness ?
with gas or injection is good for the vertical climb and from what ive heard there is overheating probs when the GMH v8 is fitted where the GMH v6 is a better way to go?????
but a dirty old diesel is good for any time
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 9:17 pm
by shorty_f0rty
itd recommend the 3b as well.. you can have it on some nasty angles running without any problems for a while.. i was stuck with my nose in the air in a precarious position for about 5mins all the time with my foot on the brake and the engine running. and it just kept on chuggin..
im also looking to turbo the 3b and reckon it'll be a worthwhile investment long term.. better than standard performance and a bit more get up and go.
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 9:53 pm
by bj42turbo
I reckon go the petrol
Only joking, go the 3b or even better add a hairdriyer or go a imported 13bt
Tidy42 it's a sickness
we all need to see someone about it
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 11:01 pm
by Iava64/40
Thanks for that. Now i have to save my pennys
Posted: Mon Jan 10, 2005 11:27 pm
by spazbot
go the V8
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2005 7:17 am
by dumbdunce
it comes down to what you want to spend and what you expect to get from the vehicle. if you just want dumb big cheap power and don't care about fuel consumption or off road performance, get a petrol V8 in there. if you want good offroad ability and don't care how fast it goes, the 3B is hard to beat. if you want performance and economy then you have to spend big on the 14B-T or similar. ofr any of those options you are better off ditching the 3 speed boat anchor and getting a newer 4 or 5 speed with split transfer case, there are a greater variety of adaptors available for the newer ones and they are stronger and nicer to drive.
cheers
Brian
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2005 11:36 am
by matt g
Hi All,
Hearing about the 14-BT - how similar is that to the 13-BT, and do you have any issues with power electrical systems (12/24v), or diesel sulphur levels etc?
These have both been suggested to me as worry items with import MWBs with the japanese spec 13-BT
Thanks
Matt
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2005 2:44 pm
by dumbdunce
matt g wrote:Hi All,
Hearing about the 14-BT - how similar is that to the 13-BT, and do you have any issues with power electrical systems (12/24v), or diesel sulphur levels etc?
These have both been suggested to me as worry items with import MWBs with the japanese spec 13-BT
Thanks
Matt
nothing that can't be fixed - the jap fuel requirements are probably more stringent than here anyway.
electrically the 14B-T can be 12 volt converted. glow plugs and starter motor is about it.
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2005 3:47 pm
by matt g
Hey Dumbdunce,
So with stricter fuel requirements in Japan is that not going to make the motor unhappy with fuel quality here, or is it only a problem in the reverse situation? We're changing over to a stricter diesel soon here aren't we?
Starter motor and glow plugs? OK, are they the sort of thing likely to be problematic if you were to break down outside a major population centre?
Cheers
Matt
t
Posted: Tue Jan 11, 2005 8:32 pm
by DIRTY ROCK STAR
Hey mate i have a 2F go the Diesel!
and if u had 5k to spend which im gueesing u dont, fack the 14bt off, get a CHEV V8 Diesel!!!!!!!!!!!!
V8 and diesel best of both worlds...
but in reality a 2H or 3B would be your go....
but.... get rid of that 3 speed!!!! get a 4 speed box, spend 200 bucks treat yourself!
Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2005 6:53 am
by dumbdunce
matt g wrote:Hey Dumbdunce,
So with stricter fuel requirements in Japan is that not going to make the motor unhappy with fuel quality here, or is it only a problem in the reverse situation? We're changing over to a stricter diesel soon here aren't we?
yes I believe that is the situation, but no guarantees. If your pump does have problems due to fuel quality, it is repairable, but not necessarily cheap. The same problems occur with locally available diesels, so if you're going diesel it's something you have to consider no matter where you buy the motor from.
Starter motor and glow plugs? OK, are they the sort of thing likely to be problematic if you were to break down outside a major population centre?
Cheers
Matt
use the same glows and starter as the locally available 13B-T so not likely to be a problem. they are pretty reliable anyway and even if the glows go out, direct injection motors are pretty easy to start without glows, and the starter motor is common to the whole B family, so landcruisers, dyna trucks etc have the same - should be able to get them anywhere.
no EDIC on the direct injected motors so no 12/24v worries there.
cheers
Brian
Posted: Wed Jan 12, 2005 11:49 am
by bad_religion_au
and if your glowies go out and it's a huge problem, boil a couple of litres of water and slowly tip it over the head, should get enough heat in there... worked on my H up mount hotham in ski season
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2005 6:55 am
by Iava64/40
I was ust looking at a 71 the other day and to change from a 3 speed to a 4 and had to cut the cross member out (that is the curcular one). What is the legal or enginering iplications to that
t
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2005 11:41 am
by DIRTY ROCK STAR
Iava64/40
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2005 6:55 am
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I was ust looking at a 71 the other day and to change from a 3 speed to a 4 and had to cut the cross member out (that is the curcular one). What is the legal or enginering iplications to that
who cares, put another one in near it.
its old, no one will know its not legit.
and "it was like that before you got it" "your not an automotive engineer" so it isnt your problem.
Posted: Fri Jan 14, 2005 11:41 am
by Andy_B
Go the diesel, it's tough as nail that engine. you can kick it in the balls and it well keep going. Went all the way up to Cape York and never had an issue. As for Transmisions I would get a 5 speed. The 4 speed for touring sucks, and uses more fuel.