Outer Limits 4x4 Board

i am in the market for some new rubber i currently run 34x11.5 JT2's and its time to upgrade and i cant decide what to get im looking at 35 extreme trekkers 2's, i got a awsome price on 35x12.5 maxxis mudzilla's, or xterrains i just want some feedback on peoples opinions i have done all my research but it all seems to come down to peoples preference.

Looks by your pic that you like a bit of mud..

X-Terrains are great for on road, dirt and rock, but not too crash hot in the mud.

I haven't used the others, so can't comment too much on them, but would think the ET's would be the way to go.