Notice: We request that you don't just set up a new account at this time if you are a previous user.
If you used to be one of our moderators, please feel free to reach out to Chris via the facebook Outerlimits4x4 group and he will get you set back up with access should he need you.
Recovery:If you cannot access your old email address and don't remember your password, please click here to log a change of email address so you can do a password reset.

200 - 250amp welders bang for $$

General Tech Talk

Moderators: toaddog, TWISTY, V8Patrol, Moderators

Post Reply
Posts: 810
Joined: Thu Jul 15, 2004 8:02 am
Location: Somewhere in NSW

200 - 250amp welders bang for $$

Post by brighty »

What type of mig welders are the best quality/usability vs $$ in the 200-250 amp range?? I know the more you spend the better quality but just wanted peoples thoughts & experiences as I know there would be plenty of ppl on here with different types.

Yes I have searched but couldn't find the right info I wanted. If someone can point me to a previous topic or post it'd be a great help.

Cheers.
When in doubt..... UTE-ERIZE it!!!
Posts: 1644
Joined: Thu Aug 03, 2006 9:50 pm
Location: Hawkesbury, Sydney

Post by CWBYUP »

Uni Mig 240 has been good for me.

Just over $1100 with the long leads.

Nick
[quote="Vulcanised"]more grunt than a row of drunk girls at a B&S ball!
[/quote]
Posts: 2513
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2005 1:14 am
Location: ingleburn

Post by familybus »

Migo-Mag 260 with remote head! mmmmmmmmmm i lurv mine, easy to use and reliable for the next 100 years! :D
[color=lime][b]Im not a gyno but ill take a look at it for you![/b][/color]
Posts: 2169
Joined: Fri Jun 16, 2006 4:41 pm
Location: melbourne

Post by joeblow »

yes...mig-o-mag....x2.
lwb 1.6efi,4sp auto,f&r airlockers,dual t/cases.custom coils.builder of ROAD LEGAL custom suzukis...and other stuff.
CAD modelling-TECH drawings-DXF preparation.
http://www.auszookers.com/index.php
Posts: 1857
Joined: Fri Feb 02, 2007 12:16 am
Location: ipswich

Post by nastytroll »

we have a 260 mig o mag at work and it is gutless compared to the lincon and WIA. Seems like and OK welder, I dont know how they compare price wise.
Posts: 1644
Joined: Thu Aug 03, 2006 9:50 pm
Location: Hawkesbury, Sydney

Post by CWBYUP »

familybus wrote:Migo-Mag 260 with remote head! mmmmmmmmmm i lurv mine, easy to use and reliable for the next 100 years! :D
But at what price ?

When i was looking at these I couldn't justify the price but that was a fair few years ago now.

What are they pulling these days ?
[quote="Vulcanised"]more grunt than a row of drunk girls at a B&S ball!
[/quote]
Posts: 446
Joined: Wed Jun 30, 2004 12:14 pm
Location: Perth

Post by bulldogy »

WIA is the best i have found wxcept an old kempi welder years ago.
Couple of workshops i know use the WIA single phase for almost all there fab work then use the lincons to to the heavy duty stuff CIG are crap mig o mag are ok but WIA seems the best. IMO
Posts: 1575
Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2006 6:50 pm
Location: Moronfield....

Post by nottie »

For a well priced home unit im for the uni-mig aswell.
Posts: 722
Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2006 7:40 pm
Location: QLD

Re: 200 - 250amp welders bang for $$

Post by zagan »

brighty wrote:What type of mig welders are the best quality/usability vs $$ in the 200-250 amp range??

I know the more you spend the better quality but just wanted peoples thoughts & experiences as I know there would be plenty of ppl on here with different types.

Cheers.
I wouldn't go around buying welders based on price.

Go by what you like in a welder.

You can get a uni-mig single phase for $1000 to $1500 but a Lincoln can cost around $2000 $3000+ grand.

but that doesn't mean a the Lincoln will be better than the uni-mig.

I haven't used many single phase welders myself but I have used a few 3 phase welders WIA 300amp, CIG 330amp, Liquid Arc/Lincoln 280amp to 450amp, and some other old brand welders.

I like the WIA and the CIG brand welders, nice steppings with plenty of wire feed range over a stepping.

I'm currently using a liquid arc welder all day, far too many steppings so the wire feed can't feed to the highest steeping you can set.

The other problem seem to be with the wire feed wheels, using the liquid arc wire it'll slip lol (it's too oily), but using cig or wia wire won't slip.

Also the wheel nut can be over tighten, which can push the lower wire feed wheel in too far and the wire won't line up with the wire groove on the lower wire feed wheel.

anther problem with Lincolns seem to be if your only using them at low settings all the time, you can burn out the ground nut or set up inside the welder and over time will break down and will need to be replaced which costs a bit as this part comes from the USA.

This is a common problem with the Lincoln welders, how you can around this problem is use the welder at high settings for a bit then go back to what ever the low settings are.

I've killed the CIG welder about 3 times, everything has been replaced now.

the CIG wire feed motor can burn out if your using it at very high wire feed/stepping settings, but use at a home should be fine for 99% of the time.

I still like the CIG welder heaps, because the steppings offer a wide range and you can actually get 2 sweet spots (low/high) across the whole wire feed range on the low to mid steepings.

I haven't had any problems with the WIA welders.

The UNI-MIG welders look pretty nice to me, I haven't used them yet.
Posts: 3722
Joined: Sat Jan 18, 2003 7:32 pm
Location: perth wa

Post by bazooked »

single phase lincon, cant go wrong. and just over 1k.
buggy time............
Posts: 810
Joined: Thu Jul 15, 2004 8:02 am
Location: Somewhere in NSW

Post by brighty »

Ok, so I went to a few places around home that stock welders etc... here are the prices I was quoted, but was told by all of them that they could do a slightly better deal if I knew what I wanted.

Not in order of place but just some prices I was given for different units....

Cigweld 220 $1584 inc gst
Cigweld 250 $1782 inc gst
Unimig Pro 210 $1214 inc gst
Unimig Pro 240 $1353 inc gst
WIA 8mm Mig $2140 inc gst

BOC Mig 250C $2200 incl gst (comes with 1st lot of gas(E size), gloves, 15kg wire standard helmet)

Magmate Pro 250 $1750 inc gst (comes with 1st lot of gas(E size), gloves, 15kg wire & standard helmet)

Toolex/Autoplus 250 $1599 inc gst

So my questions are.....
1. What peoples thoughts on comparisons between the units for the money they want?? (I know alot is personal preference, just think that some of you will have a better idea than i would.)
2. Are the welders such as BOC & Toolex/Autoplus rebadged units of other weel known brands??(I wasn't sure if this actually happens with welders.)

Cheers
When in doubt..... UTE-ERIZE it!!!
Posts: 561
Joined: Tue Jan 04, 2005 2:25 pm
Location: Melbourne

Post by Cossie »

Anyone heard much about the ebay cheapies? 250amp for under $700, 200amp for under $400.

They're just chinese jobbies, but are they good enough for occasional home use?
The hardest thing about owning a jeep is telling your parents you're g a y!!
Posts: 810
Joined: Thu Jul 15, 2004 8:02 am
Location: Somewhere in NSW

Post by brighty »

brighty wrote:Ok, so I went to a few places around home that stock welders etc... here are the prices I was quoted, but was told by all of them that they could do a slightly better deal if I knew what I wanted.

Not in order of place but just some prices I was given for different units....

Cigweld 220 $1584 inc gst
Cigweld 250 $1782 inc gst
Unimig Pro 210 $1214 inc gst
Unimig Pro 240 $1353 inc gst
WIA 8mm Mig $2140 inc gst

BOC Mig 250C $2200 incl gst (comes with 1st lot of gas(E size), gloves, 15kg wire standard helmet)

Magmate Pro 250 $1750 inc gst (comes with 1st lot of gas(E size), gloves, 15kg wire & standard helmet)

Toolex/Autoplus 250 $1599 inc gst

So my questions are.....
1. What peoples thoughts on comparisons between the units for the money they want?? (I know alot is personal preference, just think that some of you will have a better idea than i would.)
2. Are the welders such as BOC & Toolex/Autoplus rebadged units of other weel known brands??(I wasn't sure if this actually happens with welders.)

Cheers
Any more feedback on this???

Or what about the Magmate welders???
When in doubt..... UTE-ERIZE it!!!
Posts: 2254
Joined: Tue Dec 10, 2002 5:09 pm
Location: Sydney

Post by jessie928 »

unimig 240 is great little unit
i woudl highly recoomend it

but if you ask me, get a OLD unit, something with heaps of copper in it, not like the new style welders.
Jes
ATTACH BROKEN TOYOTA HERE--->
DUCATI <-----Worlds best warning label
Posts: 1650
Joined: Wed Jun 06, 2007 10:12 pm
Location: ipswich

Post by sloshy »

I'll vouch for the 240amp uni-mig aswell :armsup:
cheers Dan

Licenced Carpenter
I do everything, free quotes
Brisbane west/Ipswich/rural
PM me
Posts: 59
Joined: Sat Jul 30, 2005 7:00 pm
Location: wollongong nsw

Post by nick bj40 »

been keeping an eye on this one and most are on the right track

i am an 4th yr apprentice boilermaker/welder and for day to day use just about anything other than unimig and toolex and real cheapies

but in saying that if you want one to say hey i got a migwelder (which does make alot of the work easyer when it works properly) and its only use is going to be a little crack here or some bars or even bash plates then anythig is going to be beter than nothing BUT please if you spend the hard earned cookies research please.

ask for parts that do need replacing
if u dont know what these are in a rough order,

tips
wire
gas (industrial argoshield is what we use at work) (probly should be the same for any but make sure)
linners
copper gas shields
rollers

they are the basics most wont need these for a long time but u will still need after a while and there is no point in having a cheap mig welder and some rather expensive parts

and trust me some of these are expensive very expesive
82 MQ SD33T, 5 speed, 4.6 diffs, 50mm spring, 40mm body, front extened 50mm, 35' trapdors (awsum) just lovin getin out there
Posts: 300
Joined: Sun Feb 15, 2004 4:48 pm
Location: Penrith {Sydney} NSW

Post by tuff 45 »

Just bought a unimig 240 with a roll of wire for $1150 from a shop at Wetherill park NSW.
Posts: 722
Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2006 7:40 pm
Location: QLD

Post by zagan »

brighty wrote:Ok, so I went to a few places around home that stock welders etc... here are the prices I was quoted, but was told by all of them that they could do a slightly better deal if I knew what I wanted.

Cheers
if you havn't already but simply have a think about what you want to weld then the thickness of the metals and types of metals you want to weld.

I take it would be bullbars/rear bars, maybe some tables for the garage, etc thjis would be mainly mild/stainless steels, say 3mm to 8mm thick.

think about things like that and then go back to the shop with what you come up with and they'll be able to help you out.

As for BOC I havn't seen them really at the welding shop I goto, just Uni-Mig, Liquidarc/lincoln, CIG, SIP, PECO and WIA.

For me I think of CIG and BOC being the same deal, I havn't heard of toolex welders.

240amp will be able to handle 3mm to 6mm steel easy, pushing out to 8mm maybe 10mm as long as you not going nuts on 10mm steel all the time.
Posts: 1650
Joined: Wed Jun 06, 2007 10:12 pm
Location: ipswich

Post by sloshy »

zagan wrote: 240amp will be able to handle 3mm to 6mm steel easy, pushing out to 8mm maybe 10mm as long as you not going nuts on 10mm steel all the time.
Maybe 10mm :?

My uni-mig 240 is mostly for home fab work but I do use it a little bit for work like welding 13mm thick C beams/ posts under lifted houses, welds them a piece of piss, gets heaps of good penetration, even upside down and verticals, and I have never had it cut out with too much continuous use.
cheers Dan

Licenced Carpenter
I do everything, free quotes
Brisbane west/Ipswich/rural
PM me
Posts: 3288
Joined: Sun Feb 02, 2003 10:15 pm
Location: Central West NSW

Post by Slunnie »

brighty wrote:Ok, so I went to a few places around home that stock welders etc... here are the prices I was quoted, but was told by all of them that they could do a slightly better deal if I knew what I wanted.

Not in order of place but just some prices I was given for different units....

Cigweld 220 $1584 inc gst
Cigweld 250 $1782 inc gst
Unimig Pro 210 $1214 inc gst
Unimig Pro 240 $1353 inc gst
WIA 8mm Mig $2140 inc gst

BOC Mig 250C $2200 incl gst (comes with 1st lot of gas(E size), gloves, 15kg wire standard helmet)

Magmate Pro 250 $1750 inc gst (comes with 1st lot of gas(E size), gloves, 15kg wire & standard helmet)

Toolex/Autoplus 250 $1599 inc gst

So my questions are.....
1. What peoples thoughts on comparisons between the units for the money they want?? (I know alot is personal preference, just think that some of you will have a better idea than i would.)
2. Are the welders such as BOC & Toolex/Autoplus rebadged units of other weel known brands??(I wasn't sure if this actually happens with welders.)

Cheers
We run 2x BOC 190 Industrials, which I assume are similar to the 250 apart from the remote feeds. I'm not partilcularly impressed by them to be honest and dont get the reliability of duty cycle out of them which is needed. I understand they are manufactured by Kempi.

We've had a look at the Magmate Pro's and we may give these a run later. They are great in the spec with Euro fittings and excellent duty cycles, but I'm not sure if they're heavy duty enough.

The other one we may give a run is the Air-Liquide for some Aluminium mig work.
Cheers
Slunnie

Discovery TD5, Landy IIa V8 ute.
Posts: 12
Joined: Tue Jul 29, 2008 2:18 pm
Location: tas

welder

Post by 350hplux »

mate ,if you have acess to 3ph power get an old cig transpak 180 . i bought one 20 yrs ago for $300 and they are the grouse . the unimigs are sold by my brother down here and are not a bad machine except for the duty cycle but when fitted with an extra cooling fan and a heavy duty earth lead they are as good as any single phase mig. cheers darin
Posts: 45681
Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2002 10:13 am

Re: welder

Post by bogged »

what did ya get? are ya happy with it?
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests