Notice: We request that you don't just set up a new account at this time if you are a previous user.
If you used to be one of our moderators, please feel free to reach out to Chris via the facebook Outerlimits4x4 group and he will get you set back up with access should he need you.
Recovery:If you cannot access your old email address and don't remember your password, please click here to log a change of email address so you can do a password reset.

Is gasless MIG as good as ARC?

General Tech Talk

Moderators: toaddog, TWISTY, V8Patrol, Moderators

Forum rules
Post Reply
User avatar
Emo
Posts: 4137
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2004 12:46 pm
Location: Sunshine Coast

Is gasless MIG as good as ARC?

Post by Emo »

I've had a little CIG ARC welder for a while but not long ago I managed to pick up a Lincoln Electric SP170t MIG. I've got a gas bottle so most of my welding will be with gas but if I need to weld outside I can swap the roll and weld gasless. I don't have much experience with gasless MIG welding. Is it as good as ARC welding? I'm just tring to figure out if I need both the MIG and the ARC welders or whether I can unload the ARC.
Top
Posts: 1048
Joined: Sat Jul 17, 2004 9:48 am
Location: Waikerie; SA

Post by Eddy »

NO!





You are better off with the gas or the arc, even outside.

except on galv ... gasless is ok on gal.

Keep the stick welder. there are heaps of jobs that just don't warrant setting up gas pressure, wire speed etc etc ... then there's the time, probably late friday night. You need a good strong weld, probably the tow bar, or bull bar ... and you're out of gas ...
'03 Mazda Bravo Plus
'80 Datto 720 Ute
'77 Leyland Terrier Truck ... yes a real truck
Top
Posts: 7345
Joined: Wed Jun 02, 2004 3:29 pm
Location: Melbourne

Contact:
Contact Gwagensteve

Post by Gwagensteve »

I'd keep the arc.

Swapping spools and polarity is a PITA.

Steve.
[quote="greg"] some say he is a man without happy dreams, or that he sees silver linings on clouds and wonders why they are not platinum... all we know, is he's called the stevie.[/quote]
Top
Posts: 345
Joined: Mon Aug 04, 2008 8:48 am

Post by chpd80 »

You need a good strong weld, probably the tow bar, or bull bar ... and you're out of gas ...
Flux cored wire can give an equally strong weld when done correctly. Usually people who bag it have not done the time to work out the correct settings/speed/heat/etc and find gas easier probably wasting more than they are using.

Strength comes from a clean weld with the correct penetatration not from the shielding gas used. but yeah can be a pain to change polarity over and the reels.
Top
User avatar
Guy
Posts: 10366
Joined: Thu Dec 12, 2002 8:43 am
Location: Wangaratta

Post by Guy »

chpd80 wrote:
You need a good strong weld, probably the tow bar, or bull bar ... and you're out of gas ...
Flux cored wire can give an equally strong weld when done correctly. Usually people who bag it have not done the time to work out the correct settings/speed/heat/etc and find gas easier probably wasting more than they are using.

Strength comes from a clean weld with the correct penetatration not from the shielding gas used. but yeah can be a pain to change polarity over and the reels.
While all true .. it is far easier for the novice (IE most of the people who wold ask this kind of question) to get a strong weld with decent penetration under most conditions using a trusty old ARC welder.
" If governments are involved in the covering up the knowledge of aliens, Then they are doing a much better job of it than they do of everything else "
Top
Posts: 1048
Joined: Sat Jul 17, 2004 9:48 am
Location: Waikerie; SA

Post by Eddy »

love_mud wrote: .. it is far easier for the novice (IE most of the people who wold ask this kind of question) to get a strong weld with decent penetration under most conditions using a trusty old ARC welder.
My point exactly.

I'm happy to go out and weld up a tow bar or whatever with my little gasless, but it really is a PITA compared to grabbing the arc ...
'03 Mazda Bravo Plus
'80 Datto 720 Ute
'77 Leyland Terrier Truck ... yes a real truck
Top
Posts: 322
Joined: Fri May 21, 2004 12:10 am

Post by Steve F »

I just bought one of those inverter ARC welders. Couldn't be anymore convenient. After mucking about with it a bit and seeing the welds I can do with it it's my preferred welder since most of the stuff I do is bar work etc. I wouldn't bother with a gasless mig.

Cheers
Steve
Top
User avatar
Emo
Posts: 4137
Joined: Thu Jan 15, 2004 12:46 pm
Location: Sunshine Coast

Post by Emo »

Thanks for the replies. Looks like I'll be keeping the ARC welder.
Top
User avatar
V8Patrol
God of Magnificant Ideas!
Posts: 6774
Joined: Mon Aug 04, 2003 11:22 am
Location: Balls Deep

Post by V8Patrol »

Emo wrote:Looks like I'll be keeping the ARC welder.
Smart move


Both welders have a place in a decently setup w/shop or a real blokes shed
:D


I have 2 arcs, a DC inverter & a 140amp Peerless thats older than me !
2 migs , a euromig, and a SAF 320
1 tig that is AC/DC for alloy and it also does plasma cutting and DC welding......




&




I have plans to buy another soon

;)
[color=blue][size=150][b]And your cry-baby, whinyassed opinion would be.....? [/b][/size][/color]
Top
Posts: 721
Joined: Sun Apr 24, 2005 3:01 pm
Location: on top of a large pile of rocks

Post by AFeral »

Got a 210 amp WIA mig welder at work set up for stainless. If welding thicker stainless I will grab the 170 amp arc welder with some 3.2mm rods as it will give a better weld.
Flux core works great (don't forget to swap the polarity) but generally need more amps to give the same result as a solid wire and gas setup.
For ease of use mybe tack out side with the arc, unbolt and bring inside and weld up with the mig.
Those little lincoln sp170 welders are great.
Anything is possible, it just comes down to time and money.
Ferals build www.outerlimits4x4.com/ftopic164570.php
Top
Post Reply

Return to “General Tech”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 128 guests