Neither is going to help in this case.
Dan, cross your car up with the steering at lock. you will find that your tyre is in contact with a lot of that bumper bracket, not just a corner, or 1" of it.
I think that the tyre will be touching hard on that bracket about 1/2 way up the tube. that means that almost no amount of shackle lift will help unless the shackles are so long (I'm thinking about 4"-6" over stock) that the axle can't reach the bumpstop. This is not safe or feasible.
You will have to space your bumpstops to prevent this problem. Try a 2" over stock length shackle and add 1" to the bumpstop. This might allow you to get away with it.
I am not aware of any cars in the club that still have the bumper bracket in place.
Steve.
PS, yes longer shackles do make the suspension work better. but they are a really dumb way to gain clearance or lift the car.
I have never had to repair any cars because of one of my BL's, and I have done about 15 cars all up now. I have seen dodgy body lifts cause all sorts of damage though, but even stock sierras (if they have been flogged hard enough) will split the chassis around the body mounts.
If you are trying to run a decent sized tyre with a SPUA car then a BL becomes necessary. There is no place for a BL on a SPOA car- yet I keep seeing them

they make sierras scary as hell.
[quote="greg"] some say he is a man without happy dreams, or that he sees silver linings on clouds and wonders why they are not platinum... all we know, is he's called the stevie.[/quote]